Difference between revisions of "Talk:Magic Effects"

Talk:Magic Effects (edit)

Revision as of 22:20, 13 May 2006

1,559 bytes added , 22:20, 13 May 2006

no edit summary

Anonymous user

imported>DragoonWraith

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
+== New Schools? ==
 Is it possible to create your own magic school? -FViral
@@ Line 4: / Line 5: @@
 And please remember to sign your posts. I figured out how! You can do so by typing four tildes (~), or by hitting the tool button second in from the right. --[[User:Stickman|Stickman]] 17:21, 26 March 2006 (EST)
+== Editting Spell Effects? ==
 Hm, seems you can't edit spell effects either. Such as, making a spell last longer than it's coded for. Or perhaps I'm missing something, will have to look into the TES more. [[User:Landeyda|Landeyda]] 08:03, 27 March 2006 (EST)
@@ Line 11: / Line 14: @@
 You can't edit spell effects, but you can activate a script using a spell and use whatever visual effect you want.
 --[[User:Sagron|Sagron]] 18:58, 31 March 2006 (EST)
+== Hard-Coded Spell Effects are BAD ==
 Some effects like spray are not used in the game at all and therefore can't be used without changing an existing effect. This inability to make new magic effects is pretty lame.
 --[[User:Lap|Lap]] 17:05, 2 April 2006 (Central)
-/signed, I thought after five years we'd be able to add spell effects. This is supremely annoying. --[[User:Halo112358|Halo112358]] 04:03, 3 April 2006 (EDT)
+:/signed, I thought after five years we'd be able to add spell effects. This is supremely annoying. --[[User:Halo112358|Halo112358]] 04:03, 3 April 2006 (EDT)
 :To clarify: there's no way to create a new conceptual ''spell effect'' that can be used with the custom spellmaker in game. As an example, say I want to create a fire spell effect that damages undead only, and I'd like to be able to create custom spells with the spellmaker that incorporate this effect. Ideally I'd be able to clone the fire damage effect and specify an effect script that runs while the effect is active - it would be something like if ( targetActor.isUndead ) { targetActor.applyFireDamage magnitudeOfSpell }.
 :I can fake this right now by creating custom spells and attaching scripts, but there's no way to use the spellmaker to generate custom spells with the script attached.--[[User:Halo112358|Halo112358]] 21:23, 9 April 2006 (EDT)
-Yeah, it is lame. The amount of stuff they have hard coded seems unnecessary. I've been messing with enabling bound enchantments. I checked the enchanting box in magic effects, looked at the spells, looked at the settings, etc... I can't get it to work. Either I'm missing something not covered in the wiki or obvious in other spell effects or something hard coded is preventing it from working. Seems to me they could easily release a patch that moves this stuff out of the program code and into a new ESM, with an updated CS to add settings for new effects, schools of magic, skills, or anything else we wanted to add. Its also possible that its not hard coded at all, just hidden in the ESM in some section the CS isn't designed to access. Putting that stuff in the actual engine code just doesn't make sense. [[User:MegaBurn|MegaBurn]] 03:40, 12 April 2006 (EDT)
+:Yeah, it is lame. The amount of stuff they have hard coded seems unnecessary. I've been messing with enabling bound enchantments. I checked the enchanting box in magic effects, looked at the spells, looked at the settings, etc... I can't get it to work. Either I'm missing something not covered in the wiki or obvious in other spell effects or something hard coded is preventing it from working. Seems to me they could easily release a patch that moves this stuff out of the program code and into a new ESM, with an updated CS to add settings for new effects, schools of magic, skills, or anything else we wanted to add. Its also possible that its not hard coded at all, just hidden in the ESM in some section the CS isn't designed to access. Putting that stuff in the actual engine code just doesn't make sense. [[User:MegaBurn|MegaBurn]] 03:40, 12 April 2006 (EDT)
 :--[[User:Kkuhlmann|Kkuhlmann]] 08:40, 12 April 2006 (EDT): There's nothing "hidden" in the ESM. The CS that you've got is exactly the one we used to make the game. Magic effects being hardcoded became a headache for us as well, but there were other priorities for the programmers and we worked around it.
@@ Line 27: / Line 32: @@
 :--[[User:Kkuhlmann|Kkuhlmann]] 08:40, 12 April 2006 (EDT): I've been on the project for the duration and there was never a scroll-writing minigame proposed or designed. It's a cool idea, but we couldn't include everything... As far as "one constant effect per item" -- not sure what you mean. You can make an enchantment (in the CS) with any number of effects that you want.
 ::--[[User:Mrflippy|Mrflippy]] 12:32, 12 April 2006 (EDT) You can only have one enchantment per item however. If you want to have more than one effect, you have to create a new enchantment. This makes it more difficult to have items with multiple effects because you'll end up having to make a bazillion enchantments.
-Kkuhlmann, I mean during game play, for all of that. Now impossible to create enchanted items during game play that have anything remotely akin to the magic effects of other pre-existing enchanted items, without using special scripted items. Before players were able to create two extremely powerful enchanted item, using souls of the Tribunal "gods", some mods also added creatures with larger souls. Now the enchantment options are very limited. I've been looking for solutions to these problems but there are no settings in the CS that control the number of constant effect enchantments the PC can add. I can't find a means of enabling arrow enchantment in game, or scroll enchantment.
+::Kkuhlmann, I mean during game play, for all of that. Now impossible to create enchanted items during game play that have anything remotely akin to the magic effects of other pre-existing enchanted items, without using special scripted items. Before players were able to create two extremely powerful enchanted item, using souls of the Tribunal "gods", some mods also added creatures with larger souls. Now the enchantment options are very limited. I've been looking for solutions to these problems but there are no settings in the CS that control the number of constant effect enchantments the PC can add. I can't find a means of enabling arrow enchantment in game, or scroll enchantment.
-Maybe that scroll creation idea was something floating around the office when a reporter dropped in for a visit or just wishful thinking, or something. But I do remember seeing it in a preview, and I have a few ideas for how to implement it. Problem is I have no idea how to make it work with the scripting. Using rune words to form phrases just isn't practical with message box menus, it looks like there is a free form text entry box in the XML files but theres no documented function to use it. A free form text entry function to enter the runic phrases would work well. That could also be used for other stuff, like issuing more complex sets of directions to NPC's (without turning the dialog into a total mess), or just taking notes while adventuring. A new script function is required to actually make this stuff appear on parchment.
+::Maybe that scroll creation idea was something floating around the office when a reporter dropped in for a visit or just wishful thinking, or something. But I do remember seeing it in a preview, and I have a few ideas for how to implement it. Problem is I have no idea how to make it work with the scripting. Using rune words to form phrases just isn't practical with message box menus, it looks like there is a free form text entry box in the XML files but theres no documented function to use it. A free form text entry function to enter the runic phrases would work well. That could also be used for other stuff, like issuing more complex sets of directions to NPC's (without turning the dialog into a total mess), or just taking notes while adventuring. A new script function is required to actually make this stuff appear on parchment.
-For the scrolls, it would be a matter of adding a special scripted quill to trigger the scroll creation script, translating the text input (runic phrase) into a spell effect, and swapping out a sheet of plain parchment for a scripted spell effect scroll – and seeding a bunch of books across the game world with various runes and their meanings, along with sample phrases. A tutorial quest or two would be good too. Writing could be governed by speech craft so non-magic centric characters can make full use of it. Implementing this would be no small task to be sure but it would be much easier for a developer to do it, you could add a new function (or 10) to handle it rather than having to rely on a huge number of really complex scripts. Sounds to me like a prime candidate for an official mod, and well worth $1.99 to download it.
+::For the scrolls, it would be a matter of adding a special scripted quill to trigger the scroll creation script, translating the text input (runic phrase) into a spell effect, and swapping out a sheet of plain parchment for a scripted spell effect scroll – and seeding a bunch of books across the game world with various runes and their meanings, along with sample phrases. A tutorial quest or two would be good too. Writing could be governed by speech craft so non-magic centric characters can make full use of it. Implementing this would be no small task to be sure but it would be much easier for a developer to do it, you could add a new function (or 10) to handle it rather than having to rely on a huge number of really complex scripts. Sounds to me like a prime candidate for an official mod, and well worth $1.99 to download it.
-I added CS features and functions to the [[Wish_List]] to cover all of this stuff, and pretty much everything else I can think of.
+::I added CS features and functions to the [[Wish_List]] to cover all of this stuff, and pretty much everything else I can think of.
-This is getting really long for a talk page entry, but I also wanted to add that I don't mean to be disrespectful or ungrateful. I'm just pushing to make the game better. I know a great deal of effort goes into the game design, probably better than most. I'm the lead designer on Openlancer, an open source sequel to Freelancer (and Tachyon, and others). Playing Oblivion over the past few weeks has certainly helped my keep my sanity but I'm also solidly in “design mode” so I've jumped right in on modding. Oblivion is a great game but just like anything else there is always room for improvement, its a never ending cycle. Way I see it improving and expanding the script engine will probably help the modding community the most, allowing them to crank out more mods which just makes Oblivion all that much better.
+::This is getting really long for a talk page entry, but I also wanted to add that I don't mean to be disrespectful or ungrateful. I'm just pushing to make the game better. I know a great deal of effort goes into the game design, probably better than most. I'm the lead designer on Openlancer, an open source sequel to Freelancer (and Tachyon, and others). Playing Oblivion over the past few weeks has certainly helped my keep my sanity but I'm also solidly in “design mode” so I've jumped right in on modding. Oblivion is a great game but just like anything else there is always room for improvement, its a never ending cycle. Way I see it improving and expanding the script engine will probably help the modding community the most, allowing them to crank out more mods which just makes Oblivion all that much better.
 Thanks, [[User:MegaBurn|MegaBurn]] 04:17, 13 April 2006 (EDT)
 Creating a new spell, it would seem I have to use the Script Effect icon for all the custom spells? It's weird that you can enter Magic Effects but you're really not doing much more then altering minor stuff. I just find it weird to use a Burden icon for all the Script Effect spells one creates. Any workaround? --[[User:Silverljus|Silverljus]] 08:06, 23 April 2006 (EDT)
+:You can change the icon, but that changes it for all other mods. Therefore, you can have whatever icon you want for Scripted Effects, but all Scripted Effects are going to have the same icon. Which is very dumb.--[[User:DragoonWraith|DragoonWraith]] 23:20, 13 May 2006 (EDT)
 I just downloaded a mod that added Holy Damage spells but theres no Holy Damage effect.....so how the heck did the guy do it? He would have had to make his own effect, right? Some people also said that te effect shows up in the spell maker in game but I havent tried it so I dont know if its true. I want to do my own Light and Darkness effect spells but I cant figure out how this guy made the holy damage effect so I cant make my own either. Worst thing is, I dont know ANY scripting so im thinking that this is gonna be impossible with my current skills. Unless scripting it really easy to explain, im outta luck. So what I wanna know is, someone made a new effect so how did he do it? Anyone know? (Id ask the author but I dont have a very convenient way to contact him)[[User:Lugia|Lugia]] EDIT: HAH! I found the spell effects list and he edited Health Damage to be his Holy Damage thing! That explains why people were talking about other NPCs being able to do this, because he just edited an existing effect, he didnt make his own. So now the question is: "Can you add an effect? Even if you have to edit the code of the game in notepad, there should be SOME way.
+:There is no official way to add a new effect, though I imagine you could probably change that if you felt like reverse-engineering the game and adding it in (probably absurdly difficult, and likely illegal), but that's no good because you'd be the only one with the version that can do it.--[[User:DragoonWraith|DragoonWraith]] 23:20, 13 May 2006 (EDT)
+Interesting information on this topic: The game came with an extra Spell Effect, Z004 (Name: Summon 04 Extra), which might be used to create a new effect. Unfortunately, there's only one, meaning that any mod loaded after yours using Z004 will overwrite yours (or yours will overwrite someone elses), so it's pretty useless.
+There are also two effects with no use (apparently), DARK (Name: DO NOT USE - Darkness) and LOCK (Name: DO NOT USE - Lock). Attempts by Bethesda that didn't work? I don't know. There's also RSWD (Name: Resist Water Damage), which has all its settings at the default, leading me to believe it is also unused. So maybe, rather than only 1 (Z004) extra effects, there are 4 (Z004, DARK, LOCK, and RSWD). Still not very helpful (at all).--[[User:DragoonWraith|DragoonWraith]] 23:20, 13 May 2006 (EDT)